They were all born in the 80s and these are the songs that have chosen!!!! What is up with that? 
Come on…pick some good songs. Bad choices.
-
Ramiele Mulabay - pitchy and terrible. Randy Jackson called it right. Very much in danger tonight.
-
Jason Castro – don’t know if I’m crazy about the song (and I really like Sting), but Jason can sing!
-
Syesha Mercado – she sang it – but I’m still bored with it.
-
Chikezie – easily the most improved from the beginning of the competition BUT once again, what is up with the song selections.
-
Brooke White- beginning (oops). Gorgeous voice. I agree with Randy Jackson 100% – weird arrangement – should have stuck with just her and piano. (What is up with Paula Abdul’s arm/glove sleeve…is she cat-woman?)
-
Michael Johns – best so far tonight (and best for Michael). Excellent song choice. What is up with Michael and Queen? Not hinting at anything
– just asking. -
Carly Smithson- ending…not so much. But I think she is awesome! I think the judges are judging her more harshly than others. Come on…contrast criteria between Carly and Ramiele!!
-
David Archuleta – the kid has skills, but I don’t like the song. “Sounds like something he sang in show choir in high school” – Kelly Barrington. If David sings the phone book…I WILL NOT fall in love with it (thank you Paula). “Theme-park performance” - got to agree with that.
-
Kristy Lee Cook- Is this an attempt to invoke a Patriotic sentimentality to stay in the show? Pitchy. Take it to a county fair!!!
-
David Cook – Brilliant. Loved it. “I like him better than Chris Daughtery” – Kelly Barrington. Those are fighting words. Having some tension in the house this week! I think Paula is about to kiss him.
