
THREE songs tonight!
Song 1 - Judges choice
Song 2 – Contestant’s choice
Song 3 – Producer’s choice
David Archuleta- (song 1) – someone wake me up when he is done please…here comes the grandma and little girl vote. (song 2) – come on dude choose a song that goes with your voice! “A chihuahua trying to be a tiger” – Simon Cowell; (song 3) – BEST SONG HE HAS SUNG…HANDS DOWN! He may have just sealed the top two (not that it was in question)
Syesha Meracado- (song 1) – oohh…Syesha giving the Davids a run for their money! (song 2) – I’m feeling a little warm…almost feverish. Fantastic. Do we have an upset in the making? Paula and Simon are just JEALOUS. (song 3) – just don’t think you can count her out. If you would have told me from the beginning that she would be in the top 3 I would have said, “No way!” But now, I think she has every right to be there.
David Cook- (song 1) – I can’t believe Simon chose this song for him. I’m not sure. All I can think of is the Cheers episode where Frazier’s ex-wife sang this song at his son’s birthday party. Anyone see that episode? A little ADD trip there!
Kelly just declared she wanted David Cook to win. (song 2) – the softer beginning just didn’t sound right. Better at the end…but overall, I just don’t know. (song 3) – Aerosmith - Don’t Want to Miss a Thing…Yes! That was just alright with me. I think this is rigged…full orchestra, cool camera shots…who else got that? I think this is rigged.
Postscript: If they have to sing a song that was chosen for them they shouldn’t be critized for the song. There is nothing they can do about that.



Last night was the first time I have watched Idol this season. Wow! I think David Cook is very talented. I think he pulled it off!
I am not sure about Syesha. I didn’t like any of the song choices for her.
David Archuleta is good but maybe not good enough. It seems like he can only sing one style. His second song choice was all wrong for him. I think he may go home tonight but Syesha should go.
By: Tina on May 14, 2008
at 10:45 am
I think Syesha is just nothing special. She hits notes (she needs more)! I think she has an obnoxious personality!
By: Samson on May 14, 2008
at 12:50 pm
Dial idol has the davids 1 and 2 and syesha last I think that syesha will go home….And what did i tell u earlier this year THIS SHOW IS RIGGED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
By: Andrew on May 14, 2008
at 4:11 pm